In history today the only uses of whig and whiggish in butterfields. Sep 01, 2012 still, the ambiguously partial praise i offer here is not just for the whig interpretation of history but also for the unitalicized and lowercased whig interpretations of history that the book criticizes. The whig interpretation of history is not merely the property of whigs and it is much more subtle than mental bias. One small matter that struck me was the notion of whig history. After a brief period of rapid fluctuations, extending over the latter days of william and through the reign of anne, the balance of parties was determined on the accession of george i. And the term whig interpretation has been applied to both the latter and to all types of presentminded history. The whig interpretation did not refer to whig politicians, but to the 19thcentury interpretation of history as one long triumphant march of progress. World history or global history is a field of historical study that emerged centuries ago, with leaders such as voltaire, hegel, karl marx and arnold j.
Of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most in. During herbert butterfields lifetime, most historians were certain that the whig interpretation of history 1973 1931 had finished once and for all with the interpretation of history as the ratification if not the. Pdf paper i will discuss whether the history of science is necessarily a whig. His concerns, concepts, theoretical problems and conclusions are in many cases similar or even the same as theirs. At least it covers all that is ordinarily understood by the words, though possibly it gives them also an extended sense. Over the course of his career, butterfield turned increasingly to. The whiggish foundations of marxian and sraffian economics andrew kliman. The whiggish foundations of marxian and sraffian economics, cambridge journal of economics, volume 38, issue 3. Still, the ambiguously partial praise i offer here is not just for the whig interpretation of history but also for the unitalicized and lowercased whig interpretations of history that the book criticizes. It has been said that the historian is the avenger, and that standing as a judge between the parties and rivalries and causes of bygone generations he can lift up the fallen and beat down the proud, and by his exposures and his verdicts, his satire and his moral indignation, can punish unrighteousness, avenge the injured or reward the innocent. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Both terms do, however, carry on oblique afterlives in notions such as those of tory radicals and tory radicalism or whiggish and the whig interpretation of history. Reviews of butterfields books are fully listed in sewell, k. During this period, the whigs attempted to pass a bill excluding the brother to then king charles ii.
It might be called the historians pathetic fallacy. Whig history could first be said to have originated during the 19th century in histories of the english civil war. Part of the studies in modern history book series smh. Butterfields critique of the whig interpretation springerlink. Browse the worlds largest ebookstore and start reading today on the web, tablet, phone, or ereader. Events occurring before written record are considered prehistory. Herbert butterfield 19001979 was a british historian and philosopher of history, who also wrote christianity and history and the origins of history. Whig history and the intellectual origins of the american revolution colbourn, trevor on. Why whiggish wont do rebekah higgitt science the guardian. The importance of that essay is not just that it attained the status of a classic in butterfields own lifetime, and has continued to be reprinted for over fifty years. During herbert butterfields lifetime, most historians were certain that the whig interpretation of history 1973 1931 had finished once and for all with the interpretation of history as the ratification if not the glorification of the present butterfield, 1973 1931, p. Like much of butterfields work elegant and teasing you think its saying something important but youre not quite sure what it actually is. Whig history and presentcentred history the historical.
Sometimes specific items are mentioned that are said to justify this label, but sometimes it would. Do you think it was inevitable that the usa would one day have a nonwhite president. Butterfields main claim now seems uncontentious essentially he argues against a teleological interpretation of history which sees it as forever approaching an endpoint our modern liberal world. Whig history and presentcentred history, historical journal, vol. Article information, pdf download for whigs and stories. Key, whig interpretation of history, based on my article in a global encyclopedia of historical writing, ed. Good books on pacific history for classroom use ed, alli suhonen, 1999 glossary of historical terms for students ed, asofou soo, 2000. The whig interpretation of history of 1931 hereafter, the whig interpretation was a sustained critique of the motivation, methods and fallacious conclusions of the whig practice of staging historiographical narratives anachronistically so as to produce a ratification of the present, or justification of a position currently espoused by the. This book is a critical essay on the whig interpretation of history according to the theory standing behind, i. Ashplant, whig history and presentcentred history, the.
The whig theory of history began in the early to mid19th century, and it has taken over. In the whig view, english history was the story of a struggle for the recovery of political and religious liberty which, they held, had been lost at the time of the norman conquest. Sir herbert butterfield was a british historian and philosopher of history who is remembered chiefly for two books a short volume early in his career entitled the whig interpretation of history 1931 and his origins of modern science 1949. School of humanities and social sciences, liverpool polytechnic.
The opposition whig and tory has long ceased to be a fundamental buildingblock of political discourse in the englishspeaking world, but across the restoration and long. Were you pleased when president obama won the us election. Review of herbert butterfields the whig interpretation of. When the victorians asked themselves how they had come to live in such an apparently perfect society, they looked for an explanation to the history of england. Whig and toryhistorical outline george mason university. The whig interpretation of history by butterfield, herbert and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. I shall argue that marx has been a victim of the third strategy. Is whig history considered to be bad history, or are there authors who are proud of doing whig history and explicitly propagate it. In its golden age it was a major growth field in the 1960s and 1970s among scholars, and still is well represented in history departments. Events occurring before written records are considered prehistory. Read today comes across as tamer and more obvious in hindsight that its reputation suggests. Eliohs butterfield the whig interpretation of history 2.
Whig history and presentcentred history adrian wilson. Although butterfields generation of historians learned to be suspicious of stirring narratives that played fast and loose with. The frustrated historian s short cutswhat we will call research compromisesare drawn from the present and imposed on the past. In the whig interpretation of history, herbert butterfield critiques historians who let their perception of the present influence their study of the past. Whig history or whig historiography is an approach to historiography that presents the past as. Ernst mayr increasingly often in recent critiques of books and articles in the history of science an author is accused of having written whig history. It sees history as always progressing toward the abolition of arbitrary differences between people.
The whig view of history has also been adopted by some historians of the american west, who see the. Project muse the herbert butterfield problem and its. Whiggish people almost universally the great and the good among white men. It was a sort of subset of the historicism paradigm, however many of the whig ideas persisted well into the structuralist age from c. Of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the. The book might have vanished almost unnoticed had it not been reprinted in 1950, after butterfield published a bestselling volume, christianity and history, which attracted enormous attention.
Whiggish foundations of marxian and sraffian economics. The following study deals with the whig interpretation of history in what i conceive to be the accepted meaning of the phrase. And the term whig interpretation has been applied to both the latter and to all types of present minded history. It is part and parcel of the whig interpretation of history that it studies the past with reference to the present. Whig history and presentcentred history the historical journal. The whig narrative is the popular version of whig history.
Is whig history generally considered to be bad history. Of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the whig interpretation of history. He wrote in the preface to this 1931 book, the following study deals with the whig interpretation of history in what i conceive to be the accepted meaning of the phrase. Thus given a new lease on life, the whig interpretation of history became required reading for most history graduate students for the next quarter century, and not a few undergraduates as well. The field became much more active in terms of university teaching, text books, scholarly journals, and academic associations in the late 20th century. Presentcentred history and the problem of historical. The political history of england in the eighteenth century falls naturally into two great divisions. The seminal work in the denunciation of whig history is the whig interpretation of history, published by herbert butterfield in 1931. Whig history or whig historiography is an approach to historiography that presents the past as an inevitable progression towards ever greater liberty and enlightenment, culminating in modern forms of liberal democracy and constitutional monarchy. The whig narrative and american christianity james r. Whig partisan view of the english constitution and the whig view of history which dominated british historiography in the victorian era. Whig history and the intellectual origins of the american revolution. It is an umbrella term that relates to past events as well as the memory, discovery, collection, organization, presentation, and interpretation of information. Whig in history topic from longman dictionary of contemporary english whig whig w noun countable ppg sh a member of a british political party of the 18th and early 19th centuries which wanted to limit royal power, and later became the liberal party examples from the corpus whig likewise, we can still find examples of tories.
A guide for teachers teaching history for the first time. Its a phrase ive encountered before and understood to mean a kind of triumphalist point of view in the writing of history. May 12, 2008 one small matter that struck me was the notion of whig history. It really seems like a critique, or insult to the author when he is accused of whig history. Apr 25, 2010 5081 the whig viewof history the whig view of history is more often than not now used as a pejorative. In particular, he convincingly relates aspects of the attack on whig history to the separation of history from law in the british universities at the end of the nineteenth century and to the concomitant revolt against the anachronisms arising from the search for precedents for present practices and institutions. I realize you might not know the origins of whig and tory during the exclusion crisis of 16791863. Or that most authors and readers dont strive to suck all the joy and hope out of past, present and future events. Ashplant school of humanities and social sciences, liverpool polytechnic of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the whig interpretation of history the importance of that essay is not. Herbert butterfield author of the whig interpretation of. Whig history and presentcentred history, historical journal, 31, 1 1988. When first coined it was to describe a narrative where everything just got better all the time. Butterfield defines the whig view of history as the theory that we study the past for the sake of the present p. The whig vision of history derived from the commonlaw claim of.
A historian is a person who studies and writes about the past, and is regarded as an authority on it. Hermeneutical contributions to the history of science. History is an umbrella term that relates to past events as well as the memory, discovery, collection, organization, presentation, and interpretation. Present centred history 255 greater individualism in the gay indifference of the prolific fathers of the ancien r6gime. Excellent analysis of whig historythat is, defining the past in terms of the present.
Wih of 1931 he had applied the terms whig and whiggish to presentcentred. Historians are concerned with the continuous, methodical narrative and research of past events as relating to the human race. The influence of the present in the writing of history. Eliohs butterfield the whig interpretation of history. Wellcome unit for the history of medicine, cambridge. Examples of metanarratives are the bible, the communist manifesto and witchcraft.
Its still dominant despite criticisms in the 1930s and 40s. The example he mentions most is that of the reformation whigs. Basically, what the whig theory of history says is that history is an inevitable march upward into the light. A history of england in the eighteenth century, vol. Here was a study which resembled classical whig history in offering a broad, synthetic sweep spanning several centuries but which was diametrically opposed to whig history in its animating value judgment.
It was the cambridge historian her bert butterfield who described and condemned what. In response to these paradoxes scholars reach for a short cut through that maze of interactions by which the past was turned into our present 25. Butterfields book on the whig interpretation marked the emergence of a negative. Ashplant school of humanities and social sciences, liverpool polytechnic of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the whig interpretation of history. Herbert butterfields the whig interpretation of history. Pdf is the history of science essentially whiggish. Ashplant, whig history and presentcentred history, hj 31 1988, esp. What does it mean to have a whiggish view of history. Butterfield published the whig interpretation of history in 1931. Whig history and presentcentred history adrian wilson wellcome unit for the history of medicine, cambridge and t. Social history, sometimes called the new social history, is the field that includes history of ordinary people and their strategies and institutions for coping with life. The whig interpretation of history by herbert butterfield. Ashplant school of humanities and social sciences, liverpool polytechnic of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the whig interpretation of history the importance of that. The whig historian oversimplifies and overdramatizes, trying to draw similarities.
245 1055 768 1158 1161 1012 746 913 893 1347 1349 211 981 676 95 1197 1471 1474 1178 64 501 1482 615 1352 1109 905 1129 486 1300 1305 292